Peer Review Workshop in The Hague
Agenda and participants List
Please access the agenda of the meeting and the participants list.
Presentations and additional materials
Plenary session 1: Setting the scene
Peer Review and the quality of European Research - Raimo Väyrynen | |
Resume of the international conference 'Peer review - its present and future state (Prague 2006) - Josef Syka | |
MO Forrum on Peer Review - aims and activities - Patricia Vogel |
Keynote:
Research grants peer review ten years on - what's new and what is déjà vu? Fiona Wood |
Plenary session 2: Peer Review standards accross borders and cultures
Keynotes:
ISO 9001 accreditation of peer review within EPSRC - Douglas Niven | |
Challenges and Opportunities Facing Peer-Reveiw: A Vision for Ensuring its Strategic National Value - Toni Scarpa |
Discussants:
Peer Review in the first transnational call of Nano Science ERA NET - Paul Schuddeboom | |
Monitoring the quality of peer reveiw in FP7 trough surveys, observer feedback, and the new redress procedures: results and lessons learned - Alan Cross | |
An integrated management approach to guide peer review at the FNR - Frank Bingen | |
Training for referees and panel chairs - Anna Ledin |
Plenary session 3: Reviewing specific types of proposals: interdisciplinary and breakthrough research; networking & collaborative activities; and investments in research infrastructure
Reviewing breakthrough, high-risk and interdisciplinary research proposals - Riitta Mustonen | |
Can the three-dimensional evaluation method be aligned for potential standardisation - the case with networking and infrastructure projects - Ozlem Ekici | |
Reviewing network proposals - Erik Arnold | |
ERA-instruments: activities and peer review of infrastructure projects - Cas Maessen |
Plenary session 4 A and B: International Peer Review and the sharing of resources at the European level
Session 4 - A - International review panels and referee colleges
Introduction
Perspectives of European collaboration in Peer Review - John Marks |
Speakers
International peer review: the EUROCORES HumVIB Programme - Brian Francis | |
HERA ERANET: European Peer Review college in the Humanities - John Caughie | |
Experiences of the First ERC call - Ben Tubbing |
Communiqué
The Development of International Peer Review in Central Europe - Elod Nemerkenyi |
Session 4 - B: The sharing of resources at the European level
Communiqué
ANEP-ESF benchmarking project - Victoria Ley Vega de Soane |
Speakers
Use of information tools for evaluation of research activities - the case of Slovenian Research Agency - Tomaz Boh | |
ESF Peer Review Support and the Pool of Reviewers - Nina Kancewicz-Hoffman & Valérie Allspach-Kiechel |
Session 5: Developing an action plan for the European Peer Review
Session 6: Summary and conclusions
last update: 22/05/2008