1st Workshop of the ESF MO Forum, Stockholm, 10-11 May 2010

1st Workshop of the ESF MO Forum, Stockholm, 10-11 May 2010

The first workshop of the ESF MO Forum on Evaluation of Publicly Funded Research took place in Stockholm on 10-11 May 2010. It was kindly hosted by the Swedish Research Council (VR) and the Swedish Council for Working Life and Social Research (FAS).

Presentations and Additional Materials

Day 1  

Joint Session with the ESF MO Forum on Evaluation: Indicators of Internationalisation

Welcome and Introduction
Chair: Per Janson, VR, Sweden

Open and Welcome, Professor Arne Jarrick, Secretary General for the Scientific Council for Humanities and Social Sciences at the Swedish Research Council

Roundtable presentation of participants

PDF

Setting the scene of the workshop, Laura Marin, European Science Foundation

PDF

Presentation MO Forum Report: Evaluation in National Research Funding Agencies: approaches, experiences and case studies and Presentation MO Forum on Evaluation of Publicly Funded Research, Anke Reinhardt, DFG, Germany

PDF

Presentation MO Forum on Indicators of Internationalisation pilot study, Elisabeth de Turckheim, INRA, France 

PDF

The EUROHORCs Mandate, Ian Viney, Medical Research Council, United Kingdom

Theme 1: Latest trends in Evaluation Policies
Chair: Inger Jonsson, FAS, Sweden

PDF

Latest trends in Evaluation Policies and Methodology, Hanne Foss Hansen, University of Copenhagen, Denmark

PDF

Quality assurance, scientific and strategic evaluation: the high risks and high stakes of confusion, Rémi Barré, CNAM, France

ESF MO Forum on Evaluation of Publicly Funded Research

Theme 1: Latest trends in Evaluation Policies, contd.
Chair: Inger Jonsson, FAS, Sweden

PDF

Presentation on latest studies by Member Organisations: Three NWO evaluations: Mosaic, Rubicon, Toptalent, Margreet Bouma, NWO, the Netherlands

ESF-ALLEA Evaluation of the Research Institutes of the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences: a case study, Farzam Ranjbaran, European Science Foundation

Theme 2: Potential Topics to be addressed by the Forum
Chair: Anke Reinhardt, DFG, Germany

PDF

Development of Guidelines for Good Practices in Evaluation, Gro Helgesen, Research Council of Norway, Norway

PDF

Evaluating Impacts on science and society, Per Janson, VR, Sweden

PDF

Joint Evaluations: international comparison/evaluation of (health) research portfolios, Ian Viney, Medical Research Council, United Kingdom

Round Table Discussion on Potential topics to build the Forum Action Plan
Chair: Anke Reinhardt, DFG, Germany

Breakout by Working Groups

Day 2

     

Welcome & Overview of day's structure

Breakout by Working Groups

Plenary
Chair: Anke Reinhardt, DFG, Germany
-Report back from breakout groups (Rapporteur's Reports & Discussion)
-Future MO Fora Workshops: Objectives, Topics, Format and Next Steps

Joint Session with the ESF MO Forum on Evaluation: Indicators of Internationalisation

PDF

Update on the ENID Conference: key messages and general conclusions

PDF
PDF

Development of the Forum Action Plan & Wrap Up Session. Presentation by the 2 MO Fora Chairs

End of Workshop